Jacob Runyan, 43, of Ashtabula, and Chase Cominsky, 36, of Hermitage, Pa., were each indicted in October on felony charges of cheating, attempted grand theft and possessing criminal tools and a misdemeanor count of illegal animal ownership. They each pleaded guilty in March to the cheating and misdemeanor animal ownership charges. The remaining charges were dismissed.
“I just wanna apologize to everyone,” Cominsky said Thursday. “It’s a bad situation and it’s something I wish I could say it didn’t happen.”
Runyan called it “the most ignorant decision I’ve ever made in my life” in his apology to the court and “to everybody.”
Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court Judge Steven Gall suspended a 30-day jail sentence on the misdemeanor charge, in favor of a 10-day jail sentence. That will be followed by 1 1/2 years of probation for the felony cheating charge. If they violate probation, they could face a year in prison.
The judge also ordered each to pay a $2,500 fine, half of which can be suspended if they make a donation to an charitable organization focused on fishing and children.
The boat they used in the tournament, valued at $130,000, was forfeited to the Ohio Division of Wildlife.
Their fishing licenses were also suspended for three years — the longest suspension possible.
But the damage to their public image is likely permanent, attorneys said.
“They’re forever gonna be branded with the labels of cheaters and thieves,” said Assistant County Prosecutor Andrew Rogalski. “After today, they’ll be convicted felons. And nobody should feel bad for them, because they deserve this and they earned this.”
Attorney Gregory Gentile said both men know they’ll never again compete in a fishing tournament.
“There’s seemingly endless public humiliation for these guys. … These guys are going to have to suffer this forever; when they go on a date, when they find a job. When they get Googled, this case is gonna show up forever.”
During a September 2022 walleye fishing tournament, Runyan and Cominsky were found to have used weights to make their catches appear heavier.
“We got weights in fish,” Lake Erie Walleye Trail tournament overseer Jason Fischer can be heard in footage from the weigh-in played for the court. The crowd devolved into an angry, cursing mob.
Runyan and Cominsky were frontrunners in the tournament, up for “team of the year,” and stood to win more than $28,000 from various prize pools.
“This was the end of a long season where Jacob Runyan and Chase Cominsky had a curious run of success — such that other officials in that tournament suspected foul play,” Rogalski said.
Fischer, addressing the court, said the pair won nine of the 19 events he’s run in his career. The next-winningest team had two wins, he said.
Authorities suspected the pair of cheating in past tournaments, but haven’t found any evidence, prosecutors said.
“I guess we’ll never know about the other ones,” Fischer said.
Fischer claimed the tournament lost its permits for the Cleveland Metroparks this year, which became prohibitively expensive following the scandal.
“Cleveland Metroparks didn’t want the drama you just saw,” he said.
Metroparks spokesperson Jacqueline Gerling in response Thursday said the parks system did not deny the tournament a future permit, and it “would not prohibit the event from taking place.”
Future tournaments are expected to utilize metal detectors.