80-year-old man arrested for allegedly killing 2 teens on vacation 46 years ago

Janice Pietropola, left, and Lynn Seethaler, right, were killed in June 1973 in Virginia Beach. (Courtesy: CNN)

VIRGINIA BEACH, Va. — Virginia Beach police have accused an 80-year-old New York man of killing two teens in a case that’s gone unsolved for 46 years.

The double homicide dates to 1973, when Janice Pietropola and Lynn Seethaler, both 19, traveled from the Pittsburgh area to Virginia Beach to vacation. They were found dead on June 30 inside their oceanfront motel cottage, and their deaths were ruled homicides, police said.

After an exhaustive investigation, the case went cold, police said. The cottage where the teens were slain was destroyed, then rebuilt into motels and shops.

Last fall, Virginia Beach Police cold case investigators, working with the local prosecutor, began to aggressively research a strong lead in the case, police said.

Police on Monday arrested the accused killer: Ernest Broadnax of New York. He was arrested in New York and charged with two counts of second-degree murder and one count of rape, police said. Broadnax is awaiting extradition, police said. It was not immediately clear if he had retained an attorney.

Michael Pietropola, brother of victim Janice Pietropola, said he felt “bittersweet” about the arrest. He is happy that justice may finally be served, but it also “opened up deep wounds that had been there since 1973.”

“We hope through the trials and proceedings that we will get answers, answers that the police can’t even give us right now,” Pietropola said, “so we can get some closure, some rationalization of a crazy crime that took the lives of two beautiful teenagers.”

Mostly, Pietropola said, he hopes to be able to make some sense of what happened in Virginia Beach in 1973.

“What was going through this guy’s mind? What made him pick my sister and her friend? What drove him to this? Those are the questions that as a brother I would want for closure,” Pietropola said.

Broadnax served three prison stints in New York for assault, burglary, and attempted burglary, records show. He was released on parole in 2013.

Virginia Beach Police Chief Jim Cervera declined to describe what led to Broadnax’s arrest, other than saying it was “an advancement in technology that wasn’t available X number of years ago. Most of the technology, as you know, that’s coming online wasn’t available 10 years ago.”

Investigators, he said, just kept resubmitting pieces of evidence, which eventually paid off.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.