Good Samaritan or not? Man cited for using hammer to free dogs from car in Parma

PARMA, Ohio-- Surveillance video released by Parma police shows how a Cleveland man went from hero to wrong side of the law in the span of just minutes after police say he used a hammer to rescue two dogs left in a car.

"I wanted to get that puppy out of there and make sure that he was okay," said Richard Hill. "So at that point I decided to grab a hammer and went ahead and broke the window."

Hill says the incident began around 3:30 p.m. Saturday at the Walmart on Ridgewood Road. Hill describes noticing a car alarm going off as he walked into the store. Upon exiting, about 30 minutes later, he says the car alarm continued so he went closer to investigate. Hill says he noticed several bystanders surrounding the car telling him two dogs were inside.

He says he told Walmart personnel to make an announcement while a bystander called 911 where he admits he was informed police were on the way. Hill says he didn't know how much time the smaller dog, a near motionless puppy, had left, so he grabbed his hammer to smash the window.

"The officer was upset with me, told me that I needed to wait on him, that I should not have done that," said Hill.

Police have a different account of events, arguing they were informed about the dogs at 4:08 p.m. and arrived just minutes later at 4:12 p.m. and add it was not an abnormally hot day and the sunroof and windows were open or cracked.

"The temperature that day was about 78 degrees," said Sgt. Dan Ciryak. "So we don't condone leaving dogs in hot cars but what's reasonable and not unreasonable."

When asked if Hill should have been cited, Ciryak continued, "What do you say to the victim? She went in to buy one item. It's not like she came out with a cart full of items."

The owner of the dogs, Carly Hartman, who spoke with FOX 8 over the phone explained, "I love my dogs, would never put them in danger."

Hartman says she went into the store for less than 15 minutes and now cannot drive her new car, police describe as a 2018 Audi, because the passenger window was shattered.

Police cited Hill for criminal damaging, yet he says he does not have regrets about how he acted.

"I even told the officer I would do it again in a heartbeat," said Hill.