How Are Winter Outlooks Different Than Day-to-Day Forecasts?
Our WJW FOX8 Winter Outlook will air on Thursday, October 30th. Not long after, comments and criticisms will start pouring in stating in part that we should concentrate on getting the daily forecasts right rather than trying to forecast the weather months out. This isn’t new. It happens after each seasonal outlook. Unfortunately, this common comparison is far from accurate and much more complicated.
Actual day to day weather forecasts are developed by analyzing current conditions such as radar, satellite and other more technical parameters to make a forecast for a short period of time in the future–12 Hours, 24 hours, 36 hours, 48 hours, etc. We utilize computer model projections as guidance. These projections are getting better as more data is utilized and assimilated into faster and faster computers. Computer projections are great but they still have their limitations. This is why its important for the meteorologist to determine which projection or combination of projections are accurate. Forecast accuracy continues to climb over the years. The lead time before tornado events has increased significantly saving many lives over the last decade.
Seasonal long range outlooks (winter weather forecasts) are created by looking at the ocean sea surface temperature patterns to include the north Pacific Ocean, the tropical Pacific Ocean (ENSO – two types of El Nino, neutral or La Nina), pressure patterns over the Arctic and North Atlantic, solar cycles, stratospheric wind behavior (QBO) and other longer term variables. These elements are matched up with other years of occurrence. Finally, a best possible seasonal fit is created by “weighing” certain variables higher than others. Sometimes this works out well. Sometimes it doesn’t. I’ve learned about these variables a great deal over the years and how they effect the overall pattern. I’ll be the first to admit that I’m not the best at it. Other operational meteorologists in private industry with far more experience are excellent at determining, weighing and piecing together the pieces to the puzzle. Some refer to their analog lists as their “gold book” which not many have seen!
To reiterate, the Analog Method is a trend outlook and not for a specific forecast for a specific day. Individual storms cannot be seen this far out. Forecasts for specific days? Forget it. There is too much randomness in the atmosphere that is way beyond our abilities to simulate. However, by looking at parameters that existed in the past during other storm events, we can, for example, say that the chance of a big east coast snow storm is greater or less than in years past.
For most people, all of these forecasts and trend outlooks are lumped into one group even though each are derived using entirely different information. I get it. Its human nature to generalize and simplify complicated subjects like the science of weather prediction. We formulate concrete, black and white, overly scaled down versions of the weather. Whether its a long range winter outlook, a climate average for a wedding day, the thunderstorm chances for later this afternoon, lake effect snowfall amounts or a hurricane forecast track, its all the same weather animal to most. We subconsciously eliminate the nebulous science, weird looking equations and fancy internet computer animations in favor of a narrative that tells a better story. In short, The Old Farmers’ Almanac fits with how our brains are wired. Its simple. Its folksy with just enough science to make it credible. Why do we continue believing the Old Farmers’ Almanac? The simple answer is it makes us feel good!
While I love the Old Farmers Almanac for its articles, I’d trust an actual Meteorologist’s forecast first. I wouldn’t dismiss the scientific explanation, ignore the random changes and replace them with the Old Farmers Almanac figuring that its more accurate. The results are usually disappointing.
So remember that Winter Weather Outlooks are by their very nature formulated differently than day-to-day forecasts. Let’s sit back and see if this winter will behave like we think it will.