Pastor Defrocked for Officiating Son’s Same-Sex Wedding

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

(CNN) — A Pennsylvania minister was defrocked on Thursday after he was found guilty in a church trial for officiating his son’s same-sex wedding, according to church officials.

Frank Schaefer, 51, the pastor at Zion United Methodist Church of Iona in Lebanon, had already been suspended for 30 days in November after a jury of 13 clergy members found him guilty of officiating a same-sex wedding and being disobedient to the discipline and order of the church, according to Cathy Husid-Shamir, a Schaefer family spokeswoman.

During his 30-day suspension, Schaefer was to decide whether his advocacy on behalf of the LGBT community would prevent him from fully complying with church law in the future, according to a statement from Bishop Peggy Johnson of the United Methodist Church.

Schaefer told the Board of Ordained Ministry Thursday that he could not uphold the church’s Book of Discipline in its entirety because it discriminates against gay people.

Schaefer was asked to immediately surrender his credentials, but he refused, forcing church officials to defrock him, the statement said.

“I am somewhat in shock still,” Schaefer said at a news conference Thursday.

“When I went into the hearing this morning,” he said, “I was hopeful that it wouldn’t come to what it has come to.”

Schaefer previously told CNN’s Zoraida Sambolin that his son, Tim, asked him to officiate his wedding seven years ago, and he decided to do it “out of love for him.”

Although he once believed that homosexuality was incompatible with his Christian beliefs, Schaefer said his views on the controversial topic evolved.

“By the time our son came out, I was ready to embrace him,” Schaefer told Sambolin.

The complaint was filed by one of Schaefer’s church members, and the church leadership decided to act upon it, according to Schaefer.

The church told Schaefer he could avoid a trial if he agreed never to perform another same-sex marriage. He refused.

“I can’t commit to a statement like that, especially in light of the fact that I have two more children that are gay,” said Schaefer, who has four children.

He said he has already filed an appeal and hopes to become reinstated to the Methodist clergy.

Schaefer’s case will now be reviewed by the appeals committee of the United Methodist Church’s northeast jurisdiction. It could also go to the judicial counsel which is equivalent to the supreme court of the church, according to Schaefer’s attorney, Bill Ewing.

“I have been a part of this church for more than 20 years,” Schaefer said Thursday. “Being a United Methodist minister is the only kind of minister I know how to be.”

Ewing expects the appeal to be tried some time in 2015.

Asked of his plans until then, Schaefer said, “I will continue to be a voice for the LGBT community.”


    • Sue Cox

      It is DEFROCKED. NOT the frock. It means that he can no longer perform the rights and privileges of the church (weddings, funerals, baptism things such as that).

  • Bert Maupin

    Look you ignorant people – – homosexuality, and I’m NOT, is a born that
    way situation, in almost 100% of the cases. It is caused by the diet of
    the expectant mother and soy. Read the books “Let’s Get Well”, “Rare
    Earths, Forbidden Cures” and “Nourishing Traditions.” I know a woman
    who was so sexually traumatized by her father and I don’t know who eelse, that she could no longer emotionally respond with men. Yes, I
    have read the Bible, three times.

  • kathie

    This is simple, IMO. He worked for the Methodist Church — he disobeyed their rules — he is fired.

    End of story. No more complicated than that.

  • Karen Robinson

    So what you have read the bible 3 times. I too read alot of fiction. God said nothing of homosexuality in your book. That book was written by numerous half starved over zealous hermits hiding in caves. Hardly scholars

Comments are closed.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.