Man Claims he was Blinded at Medieval Times

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

(Photo Credit:

By KTLA News 

Buena Park, CA (KTLA) — A South Dakota couple who envisioned spending their honeymoon enjoying Orange County’s diversions — the beach, baseball and a jousting tournament between knights in shining armor at Medieval Times — apparently got more than they bargained for.

The couple have now filed a $10-million suit against the Buena Park dinner show theater, alleging that a mock sword fight left Dustin Wiseman partially blind when a shard of metal from a titanium sword flew into the newlywed’s eye.

Wiseman, 37 and his wife, Melissa, 38, were sitting in the front row at the time, according to their lawsuit.

The couple allege that the popular dinner theater failed to take proper precautions to protects its patrons, and ruined their April 2011 honeymoon.

“The only thing they actually did was go to the beach, then go to Medieval Times and go to the hospital,” said their attorney, Jason Fowler.

Fowler said the couple was talked into purchasing the VIP tickets, and that they haven’t been reimbursed for any of Dustin Wiseman’s medical expenses.

“He’s undergone at least three surgeries and still is legally blind, essentially, in his left eye,” Fowler said.

He added that the couple had to suffer through a tumultuous start to their marriage, with Melissa Fowler transitioning from newlywed to caregiver.

An attorney with Medieval Times said the law firm does not comment on pending litigation.