In November 2011, a horse owned by an Amish farmer in Ashtabula County broke loose from an auction and began sprinting for home.
It collided head-on with a car driven by Daniel Brown, 45, and both were killed instantly, along with a second man who swerved to avoid the accident.
How did this deadly accident lead to a bizarre murder-for-hire plot?
Fox 8 I-team reporter Jack Shea unravels the mystery. Click on the video player above to watch his story.